Preposition after verb

Smother in or smother by?

Smother in is used for being covered by something. Smother by is uncommon as an active pattern, but smothered by is natural in passive clauses.

Quick answer

Which form should you use?

Use smother in when someone or something is covered with a substance or quantity. Use smothered by in passive structures to show the cause or agent.

The cake was smothered in chocolate sauce.
The town was smothered by heavy smoke.
She felt smothered by constant attention.

Choose the pattern by meaning

These forms are not interchangeable. Choose the construction by meaning, not by which preposition appears most often.

1
smother in + substance

Showing complete covering

In introduces the thing covering the surface.

The fries were smothered in cheese.
He arrived smothered in mud.
2
smothered by + cause or pressure

Passive meaning of being overwhelmed

By introduces the thing causing the effect.

The valley was smothered by fog.
She felt smothered by responsibility.

See the difference in context

The same subject can take different constructions because each sentence answers a different question.

Construction
Example
Meaning
smother in
The pancakes were smothered in syrup.
Covered completely with something.
smother by
The fire was smothered by sand.
Natural mainly in passive clauses.
smother with
They smothered the vegetables with butter.
Another common pattern for covering or overwhelming.

Common mistakes

Some combinations appear in real text but do not mean what learners often assume.

Using by after active smother

Active smother usually takes a direct object, often with with rather than by.

✕ She smothered the toast by jam. ✓ She smothered the toast with jam.

Confusing in and by

In focuses on covering material, while by focuses on the cause or agent in passive use.

✕ The valley was smothered in smoke from the factory. ✓ The valley was smothered by smoke from the factory.

Quick practice

Choose the expression that matches the intended meaning.

1. The biscuits were smothered ___ cream.
2. The village was smothered ___ ash.
3. Choose the natural sentence.

Check your sentence in context

Paste the complete sentence below. Linguix checks the preposition together with grammar, spelling, punctuation, and style.

Free to try · No signup required

Frequently asked questions

Is smother in always physical?

Usually, but it can also be figurative, as in smothered in praise.

Can I use smother with instead of smother in?

Yes. Smother with is very common in active clauses.

What does smothered by attention mean?

It means receiving more attention than wanted.

Write with confidence in Linguix

Create a free account to check complete texts, apply suggestions, and save your documents.

Create a free account